Unit Economics Deep Dive: The Math That Makes or Breaks Your Business

WeWork was valued at $47 billion. They had beautiful offices, a charismatic CEO, and massive growth. But they had terrible unit economics.

For every dollar of revenue, they spent $1.50. They lost money on every single customer. They only "succeeded" by raising billions in venture capital to subsidize losses. When the money dried up, the house of cards collapsed. Today, WeWork is bankrupt.

Meanwhile, a company like Dropbox had excellent unit economics from day one. They spent $X to acquire a customer who generated $3X in profit over their lifetime. That math allowed them to raise capital, scale aggressively, and build a $10 billion business sustainably.

Unit economics is the difference between a real business and a burning pile of cash.

What Are Unit Economics?

Unit economics answer one question: Do we make money on each transaction/customer?

It's not about total revenue. It's not about growth rate. It's about the profitability of a single unit of your business.

| Business Type | The "Unit" | Key Metrics | |---------------|------------|-------------| | E-commerce | One order | Gross margin, shipping cost, payment fees | | SaaS | One customer | CAC, LTV, churn, payback period | | Marketplace | One transaction | Take rate, payment processing, support cost | | Subscription box | One subscriber | CAC, retention, COGS, shipping | | Services | One project | Billable hours, overhead allocation, utilization |

If your unit economics don't work, your business doesn't work. Scale just makes you lose money faster.

The Four Core Unit Economic Metrics

1. Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)

The Formula: Total Sales & Marketing Spend ÷ Number of New Customers Acquired

Example:

• Monthly marketing spend: $50,000
• Monthly sales spend: $30,000
• New customers this month: 80
• CAC = $80,000 ÷ 80 = $1,000 per customer

CAC by Channel: Not all customers cost the same to acquire:

| Channel | CAC | Volume | Quality | |---------|-----|--------|---------| | Paid ads | $800 | High | Medium | | Content/SEO | $400 | Medium | High | | Outbound sales | $1,500 | Low | High | | Referrals | $200 | Low | Very High | | Partnerships | $600 | Medium | High |

Smart businesses optimize for the lowest CAC highest-quality channels.

2. Lifetime Value (LTV)

The Formula: Average Revenue per Customer × Gross Margin × Average Customer Lifespan

Example (SaaS):

• Monthly revenue per customer: $100
• Gross margin: 80%
• Monthly churn: 5% (average lifespan = 20 months)
• LTV = $100 × 0.80 × 20 = $1,600

The CAC:LTV Ratio: This is the golden metric. It should be at least 3:1.

| Ratio | Assessment | Action | |-------|------------|--------| | <1:1 | Burning cash | Stop marketing, fix product | | 1:1 to 2:1 | Unsustainable | Improve retention or reduce CAC | | 3:1 | Healthy | Scale marketing | | >5:1 | Underinvesting | Increase marketing spend |

The Dropbox Example: Dropbox's early unit economics:

• CAC: $100 (viral referral program)
• LTV: $300+ (high retention, low COGS)
• Ratio: 3:1+

This allowed them to raise capital and scale. The math worked.

3. Payback Period

The Formula: CAC ÷ Monthly Contribution per Customer

Example:

• CAC: $1,000
• Monthly revenue: $100
• Monthly variable costs: $20
• Monthly contribution: $80
• Payback period: $1,000 ÷ $80 = 12.5 months

The 12-Month Rule: If payback period is under 12 months, you have a healthy business. Under 6 months is excellent. Over 18 months is dangerous—you need too much capital to scale.

| Payback Period | Cash Required to Scale | Risk Level | |----------------|------------------------|------------| | 3 months | Low | Low | | 6 months | Medium | Low | | 12 months | High | Medium | | 18 months | Very High | High | | 24+ months | Extreme | Very High |

4. Gross Margin

The Formula: (Revenue - COGS) ÷ Revenue

What Counts in COGS:

• Direct materials/labor
• Shipping/delivery
• Payment processing
• Customer support (if variable)
• Hosting/infrastructure (for SaaS)

What Doesn't Count:

• Sales & marketing (that's CAC)
• R&D
• G&A (administrative)

Margin Benchmarks:

| Business Type | Good Margin | Excellent Margin | |---------------|-------------|------------------| | SaaS | 70-80% | 80%+ | | E-commerce | 30-40% | 50%+ | | Marketplace | 20-30% | 40%+ | | Services | 40-50% | 60%+ | | Hardware | 20-30% | 40%+ |

Real Case Study: How Peloton's Unit Economics Crumbled

Peloton was a pandemic darling. Then they collapsed. Here's the unit economics story:

The Good (2019-2020):

• Hardware gross margin: 45%
• Subscription gross margin: 60%+
• High LTV (customers kept subscribing)
• Viral growth (low CAC during pandemic)

The Bad (2021-2022):

• CAC exploded (pandemic ended, had to advertise heavily)
• Churn increased (people returned to gyms)
• Hardware margins compressed (supply chain issues)
• Customer acquisition shifted to unprofitable channels

The Ugly (2023):

• LTV:CAC ratio fell below 2:1
• Payback period stretched to 24+ months
• Negative gross margins on hardware (selling at loss)
• Cash burn unsustainable

The Lesson: Unit economics can deteriorate fast. Peloton went from a $50B valuation to nearly bankrupt in 18 months because their unit economics broke.

Real Case Study: How Amazon's Unit Economics Created a Trillion-Dollar Company

Amazon's unit economics are the foundation of everything:

Retail Unit Economics:

• Low gross margins (20-30%)
• High volume
• Efficient logistics (lower per-unit shipping cost)
• Scale economies (better supplier terms)

AWS Unit Economics:

• High gross margins (60%+)
• High fixed costs (data centers)
• Low marginal costs (serving new customers)
• Massive operating leverage

Prime Unit Economics:

• $139 annual fee
• Members spend 2.3x more than non-members
• High retention (90%+ renewal)
• LTV:CAC ratio >10:1

The Magic: Amazon uses retail's low margins to drive volume, which funds infrastructure, which enables AWS's high margins, which subsidizes retail growth. The unit economics work together.

Optimizing Your Unit Economics

To Reduce CAC:

1. Double down on best-performing channels
2. Improve conversion rates (better landing pages, messaging)
3. Increase organic/referral (lower cost)
4. Reduce sales cycle (faster = cheaper)
5. Improve lead quality (better targeting)

To Increase LTV:

1. Reduce churn (better onboarding, support)
2. Increase pricing (if market allows)
3. Expand revenue (upsells, cross-sells)
4. Improve gross margins (efficiency)
5. Extend customer lifespan (stickiness)

To Improve Payback Period:

1. Reduce CAC (as above)
2. Increase initial purchase value (bundles, minimums)
3. Offer annual plans (cash upfront)
4. Reduce time to first value (faster onboarding)

To Improve Gross Margins:

1. Negotiate supplier terms
2. Reduce waste/returns
3. Automate processes
4. Raise prices
5. Optimize product mix (sell higher-margin items)

The Unit Economics Dashboard

Track these weekly:

| Metric | Formula | Target | |--------|---------|--------| | CAC | Sales & Marketing ÷ New Customers | Declining over time | | LTV | ARPU × Margin × Lifespan | Increasing over time | | LTV:CAC | LTV ÷ CAC | >3:1 | | Payback Period | CAC ÷ Monthly Contribution | <12 months | | Gross Margin | (Revenue - COGS) ÷ Revenue | Industry dependent | | Churn | Customers lost ÷ Total | <5% monthly | | Net Revenue Retention | Revenue from existing cohort | >100% |

Red Flags: Unit Economics That Don't Work

Warning Signs:

• LTV:CAC below 2:1
• Payback period over 18 months
• Gross margins below industry norms
• Churn increasing quarter over quarter
• CAC increasing while conversion decreases
• Revenue growing but unit economics deteriorating

The WeWork Warning: WeWork's unit economics were broken from day one. They spent more per location than they could ever recoup in membership fees. But they hid this with growth metrics—more locations, more members, more funding rounds. Until they couldn't anymore.

Action Steps: Fix Your Unit Economics

This Week:

1. Calculate your true CAC (include all sales/marketing costs)
2. Calculate your LTV (use actual retention data)
3. Determine your LTV:CAC ratio
4. Calculate payback period

This Month:

1. Identify your best and worst channels by CAC
2. Analyze cohort retention (are newer customers sticking around?)
3. Review gross margin by product/service
4. Build unit economics dashboard

This Quarter:

1. Test initiatives to reduce CAC (channel optimization)
2. Launch retention programs to increase LTV
3. Negotiate better terms to improve margins
4. Set targets: 3:1 LTV:CAC, <12 month payback

Conclusion: Unit Economics Are Your Foundation

You can have the best product, the best team, the best vision. But if your unit economics don't work, you don't have a business. You have a charity funded by investors.

The companies that survive and thrive—Amazon, Dropbox, Salesforce, Netflix—obsess over unit economics. They know the math of every customer. They optimize relentlessly. They scale only when the math works.

Don't grow into bankruptcy. Fix your unit economics first. Then scale.

Your Next Step: Calculate your LTV:CAC ratio today. If it's under 2:1, stop trying to grow and fix your economics first. If it's over 3:1, you have permission to scale. If you don't know the answer, you have work to do.

---

Meta Description: Learn unit economics from Peloton's collapse and Amazon's success. Get the exact formulas for CAC, LTV, payback period, and gross margin to build a business that scales profitably.